Benefits Realization: Connecting Strategic Planning to Business Objectives

CISA · Information Systems Acquisition, Development and Implementation · By Super Admin

Explore how benefits realization links strategic planning, process development, and systems development to achieve measurable business objectives.

What Benefits Realization Means for IT Auditors

Benefits realization is the result of strategic planning, process development, and systems development, which all contribute toward a launch of business operations to reach a set of business objectives. For CISA candidates, understanding this concept is essential because audits of these activities provide objective views of their effectiveness. The relationship between these three contributing elements and the ultimate business objectives they support forms the foundation for evaluating whether IT investments are delivering value.

The prevalent point of view in IT governance is that IT exists in support of business objectives. Given this assumption, every IT project should directly or indirectly result in tangible business benefits, regardless of how technical or abstract any particular IT project may be. This framing is critical for auditors, who must assess not just whether a system was built correctly, but whether it is actually delivering the business value it was intended to produce.

Figure: A flowchart illustrating the progression from strategic planning to process development, then systems development, leading to business objectives. Below, benefits realization emphasizes the outcomes of these processes.

Benefits realization

The image above illustrates how strategic planning flows into process development, then systems development, ultimately leading to business objectives and benefits realization.

The Role of Digital Transformation in Measuring Benefits

In the mid-to-late 20th century, information technology was primarily used to automate tasks, and in that era it was fairly easy to measure the benefits derived from IT. Measuring benefits was often a matter of comparing the cost and time spent to perform tasks manually versus the cost and time spent to automate those tasks. However, information technology's role today is digital transformation (DX), which refers to the integration of digital technology into all areas of a business, fundamentally changing how organizations operate and deliver value to customers. Digital transformation provides benefits that are not easily measured and often not short-term in nature.

For example, an organization that invests in a new customer relationship management (CRM) application may do so to improve its customer service in measurable ways. Shortly after implementing a CRM system, productivity may actually decrease until individuals and teams learn how to operate and fully utilize the new system. Customer satisfaction may improve in future quarters, and a year or more may be required to determine whether improvements in customer satisfaction represent an actual upward trend attributable to the new CRM. The new system can also help the organization improve its products and services, and the benefits from these improvements may not be experienced for years after implementation.

Key Performance Indicators and Post-Implementation Reviews

Measuring business benefits requires that the organization select key performance indicators (KPIs) and measure them formally and accurately over the long term. When new projects and programs are considered, business benefits should be estimated, and measurements should be taken before and after the project has completed to validate whether the project's predictions were valid. The nature of the project may require months or even years of measurements to validate project results.

Major projects should include post-implementation reviews that take place long after the project's completion — as long as 24 months, or even longer — to determine whether trends in key metrics changed as predicted. Business case development should include a description of the business benefits expected from the completed project, including how those benefits will be measured, and these key metrics should be decided before the project begins. An organization that does not agree on key metrics in advance is in danger of setting self-fulfilling metrics later on as a way of justifying the project, regardless of whether it actually benefits the organization.

Analytics, AI, and Continuous Improvement

Organizations that modernize business processes with automation often enjoy unexpected benefits, including insight gained through business analytics or business intelligence (BI), such as customer buying trends that could not have been known before. Additionally, the incorporation of artificial intelligence (AI) into business processes can further enhance these benefits by providing advanced data analysis, predictive insights, and improved decision-making capabilities. This use of analytics also leads to a more effective control environment by replacing error-prone manual processes with efficient, automated techniques.

In the spirit of continuous improvement, careful analysis of key metrics long after a project has been completed should lead the organization to consider additional improvements in its processes and technologies. Organizations may also wish to benchmark against other firms to identify best practices and other opportunities for improvement. This ongoing cycle of measurement and refinement is central to sustaining the benefits that IT investments are designed to produce.

Key takeaways

  • Benefits realization results from strategic planning, process development, and systems development working together toward business objectives.
  • Digital transformation provides benefits that are not easily measured and often not short-term in nature.
  • Major projects should include post-implementation reviews as long as 24 months or more after completion to validate metric trends.
  • Organizations that do not agree on key metrics in advance risk setting self-fulfilling metrics to justify projects after the fact.
0.0 (0 ratings)

Discussion (0)

No discussion on this article yet — be the first to comment.

Please sign in to join the discussion.