Hubs and Collision Domains in Network Topology

Network+ · Network Implementation · By Super Admin

How hubs connect network segments in star topology, create collision domains, and why they are not recommended for modern corporate networks.

Hub Functionality and Layer 1 Operation

A hub is the device that connects all the segments of the network together in a star topology Ethernet network. As a hub has no intelligence, it is a layer 1 (Physical layer) device. Each device in the network connects directly to the hub through a single cable and is used to connect multiple devices without segmenting a network. Any transmission received on one port will be sent out to all the other ports in the hub, including the receiving pair for the transmitting device, so that Carrier Sense Multiple Access with Collision Detection (CSMA/CD) on the transmitter can monitor for collisions.

This means that if one station sends a broadcast, all the others will receive it; yet based on the addressing found in the Ethernet frame, only the intended recipient will actually listen and process it. This arrangement simulates the physical bus that the CSMA/CD standard was based on, and it's why we call the use of a hub in an Ethernet environment a physical star/logical bus topology. Hubs are nothing more than glorified repeaters that are incapable of recognizing frames and data structures—the reason they act with such a lack of intelligence.

<img src="/question_assets/Network+/sg_c05f002.png" alt="A diagram of the typical hub. Bob and sally are interconnected with the hub. The mail logo mentions hey sally's question mark."/>

<figcaption>A typical hub</figcaption>

Network Traffic and Collision Issues

A broadcast sent out by any device on the hub will be propagated to all devices connected to it. And just as in a physical bus topology configuration, any two or more of those connected devices have the potential of causing a collision with each other, which means that this hardware device will create a LAN with the most network traffic collisions. Hubs are not suggested for use in today's corporate network for this reason.

The image above depicts a typical hub as you might find it employed within a small network. Since there are only two users, there isn't a problem in using a hub here. However, if there were 20 users, everyone would see Bob's request to send a packet to Sally. Most of the time, hubs really aren't recommended for corporate networks because of their limitations.

Limitations in Modern Networks

The fundamental limitation of hubs stems from their inability to recognize frames and data structures. Every transmission is simply repeated to all connected ports, creating unnecessary network traffic and increasing the probability of collisions. As network size increases, these limitations become more pronounced, leading to degraded performance and reduced efficiency.

In environments with multiple users, the collision domain encompasses all connected devices, meaning that any two devices transmitting simultaneously will cause a collision. This shared bandwidth model becomes increasingly problematic as the number of connected devices grows. The lack of intelligence in hubs prevents them from making any forwarding decisions based on MAC addresses or other layer 2 information, forcing all traffic to be broadcast to all ports regardless of the intended destination.

0.0 (0 ratings)

Discussion (0)

No discussion on this article yet — be the first to comment.

Please sign in to join the discussion.

Hubs and Collision Domains in Network Topology | SecViva