Manual and Automated Testing, and the Fundamentals of Unit Testing
GitHub Copilot · AI-Assisted Testing · By Super Admin
Testing relies on both manual and automated approaches, and unit testing—covering a small functional unit of code—offers benefits like improved code quality, documentation, refactoring, and integration, while also supporting test-driven development despite some drawbacks.
Testing an application generally relies on two complementary approaches: manual and automated. Both are critical for the success of testing, and each brings distinct strengths to the process.
Manual vs. Automated Testing
At a high level, there are two main approaches to testing: manual and automated. Both are critical for the success of testing. Manual testing has the benefit of human intuition, creativity, experience, and expert judgment. Automated tools, on the other hand, are quick and can evaluate many edge cases, and they are also effective with tedious tasks. Beyond this basic split, there are many other aspects to testing, including a variety of methodologies such as unit testing and integration testing.
Unit Testing and Its Benefits
Unit testing involves testing a small functional unit of the codebase. You initially write the test in code and then run it every time there is a change, which allows for quickly catching issues or bugs. You typically write multiple tests for each function so as to cover the various scenarios and edge cases. Besides early detection of problems with the code, unit testing offers several other benefits: code quality should improve significantly because the focus is on making sure the application meets requirements; improved documentation results from evaluating different examples of how the software is supposed to be used; refactoring is supported because unit tests help identify areas to optimize the code; and integration becomes easier because once you understand how each unit works, it is easier to understand the relationships between them, which can further improve code quality.
Test-Driven Development and Drawbacks
Unit testing also supports test-driven development (TDD), where you begin testing before writing the code. For example, when writing a function for calculating the sales tax for an ecommerce application, you would first write a unit test to evaluate the accurate results, then write the minimal code for the function to pass the tests, and once all conditions have been met, refactor the code further. With TDD, you generally write more reliable and maintainable applications. However, this does not mean unit tests or TDD should be used for every block of code, since these techniques take time and planning; sometimes a code block is straightforward and needs only a quick manual review, or the review concerns the look and feel of the UI rather than underlying logic. Unit tests may also not be effective with complex legacy systems. Other drawbacks include the difficulty of crafting the tests to focus on requirements and edge cases—especially on large projects—the maintenance burden of updating tests over time, the limited scope of unit testing since it focuses on small parts of code rather than broader aspects (which integration tests help address), and potential bias, since developers who write their own unit tests may have blind spots from being too close to the code. Despite these issues, unit tests are generally a good approach, provided you are aware of the potential drawbacks.
Key takeaways
- Manual testing relies on human intuition and judgment, while automated tools are fast and effective for tedious, edge-case-heavy work.
- Unit testing checks small functional units of code and is typically run on every change to catch issues early.
- Benefits of unit testing include better code quality, improved documentation, easier refactoring, and clearer integration understanding.
- TDD involves writing tests before code, but unit testing is not always appropriate—for example, with straightforward code, UI reviews, or complex legacy systems—and carries drawbacks like maintenance burden, limited scope, and developer bias.
Discussion (0)
No discussion on this article yet — be the first to comment.
Please sign in to join the discussion.