TOGAF and the Zachman Framework: Enterprise Architecture Models
CRISC · Information Technology and Security · By Super Admin
Compare TOGAF and the Zachman Framework as enterprise architecture models and understand how each supports governance and risk management.
Enterprise Architecture Frameworks Overview
Enterprise architecture frameworks provide structured approaches for describing and governing the relationship between business and technology. Two frameworks discussed for enterprise architecture are the Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF) and the Zachman Framework. It is important to note that both TOGAF and the Zachman Framework are enterprise architecture models, not enterprise security architecture models, though both can be applied to security architecture within the broader enterprise context.
EA frameworks differ from network architecture in that they focus on the relationship between business and technology. They are very important because they provide a view into the governance of an organization, which can provide insight into some core problems that cause risks within the organization.
The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)
TOGAF is a lifecycle enterprise architecture framework used for designing, planning, implementing, and governing an enterprise technology architecture. TOGAF could be considered a high-level approach for designing enterprise infrastructure. It is a business-driven, lifecycle management framework for enterprise architecture overall, and it can be used for information security architecture as well.
The phases used in TOGAF are: Preliminary, Architecture Vision, Business Architecture, Information Systems Architecture, Technology Architecture, Opportunities and Solutions, Migration Planning, Implementation Governance, Architecture Change Management, and Requirements Management. These phases reflect TOGAF's comprehensive, lifecycle-oriented approach to governing enterprise technology from initial planning through ongoing change management.
Figure: Flowchart of T O G A F components with interconnected stages from primary, vision, and change management.
TOGAF components.
The image above shows the TOGAF components and how the interconnected stages flow from preliminary phases through architecture vision, change management, and requirements management.
The Zachman Framework
The Zachman Enterprise Architecture Framework, established in the late 1980s, remains a dominant EA standard today. Zachman likens IT enterprise architecture to the construction and maintenance of an office building: at an abstract level, the office building performs functions such as containing office space, but as you look into increasing levels of detail, you encounter various trades, each of which has its own specifications, standards, regulations, construction and maintenance methods. Zachman can be used to develop an enterprise security architecture within the enterprise architecture.
In the Zachman Framework, IT systems and environments are described at a high, functional level and then in increasing detail, encompassing systems, databases, applications, networks, and so on. While the Zachman Framework allows an organization to examine cross-sections of an IT environment that supports business processes, the model does not capture the relationships among IT systems. Data flow diagrams are used instead to depict information flows, which is an important distinction when selecting the appropriate tool for a given architectural analysis task.
Key takeaways
- TOGAF is a lifecycle enterprise architecture framework used for designing, planning, implementing, and governing enterprise technology architecture.
- TOGAF and the Zachman Framework are enterprise architecture models, not enterprise security architecture models.
- The Zachman Framework was established in the late 1980s and does not capture relationships among IT systems; data flow diagrams are used instead.
- Zachman can be used to develop an enterprise security architecture within the enterprise architecture.
Discussion (0)
No discussion on this article yet — be the first to comment.
Please sign in to join the discussion.