Risk Treatment and Response Options: An Overview for CRISC Candidates
CRISC · Risk Response and Reporting · Bởi Super Admin
Explore the four core risk response options—mitigation, sharing, acceptance, and avoidance—and how they align with organizational mission and strategy.
Understanding Risk Response in Organizational Context
Risk treatment and response options should meet the needs of the mission, business goals and objectives, and overall organizational strategy. A risk response option focused solely on reducing risk in a vacuum may interfere with normal business operations or reduce the effectiveness of the business when performing its mission. Therefore, risk responses must reduce risk without adversely impacting business processes. Within this context, organizations should consider how to respond to risk effectively, with a balanced approach.
It is important to remember that IT risks are different from business or mission-oriented risks, and the organization's mission shapes risk responses. This is why organizations must conduct a thorough risk analysis and understand and prioritize the response options that are right for them. The risks to the business, the business goals and objectives, and the systems supporting those functions should all be considered throughout the risk response process.
Risk Mitigation
Risk mitigation generally involves the application of controls that lower the overall level of risk by reducing the vulnerability, the likelihood of a threat exploiting that vulnerability, or the impact to the asset if the risk were to be realized. Mitigation actions take many forms; a policy requiring nightly offsite backups of critical data can mitigate the risk of data loss, and applying a newly released web browser patch can mitigate the risk of exploitation. The goal is to reduce the risk to a level acceptable to the organization's leadership.
Organizations may have to add new controls, update, upgrade, or even change controls, or in some cases change the way business processes work. All of these actions are designed to mitigate or reduce risk. The key is that mitigation is not a single action but a range of possible interventions tailored to the specific risk scenario.
Risk Sharing and Risk Acceptance
Risk sharing, often referred to as risk transference, entails the use of a third party to offset part of the risk. Sharing off-site assets and contractual obligations with other entities is one way organizations implement risk sharing, and a cloud service provider can be used within this scenario. The cloud provider might be contractually obligated to assume part of the financial impact in the event of a breach, but there is a potential loss of brand goodwill or other intangible assets that can be difficult to offload. Risk sharing typically only covers a portion of the risk; it does not reduce all of the risk, nor does it transfer accountability or responsibility.
Risk acceptance occurs when the active decision is made to assume the risk—either inherent or residual—and take no further action to reduce it. The word active is critical here; risk acceptance differs from risk ignorance in that the risk is identified, alternatives are considered, and a conscious decision is made to accept it. Risk acceptance of any kind should be a formal management decision, fully documented, along with provisions for monitoring the risk, typically through the risk register.
Risk Avoidance and Evaluating All Options
Risk avoidance is the option taken when, after all risk treatment options including mitigating controls have been considered, the level of risk remains unacceptable. An organization might choose not to take on a proposed project because of the probability of failure and subsequent loss of capital, or it might choose not to adopt a cloud solution because of the sensitivity of the information that would be stored in the cloud. Risk avoidance requires careful thought and planning, as well as balancing the level of risk incurred in following a particular path versus eliminating the risk by not following that path at all.
Risk mitigation, sharing, acceptance, and avoidance are all valid options that should be considered using—sometimes simultaneously—to lower the risk an organization faces. The key is to use these options together, balancing risk and reward to maximize the benefits, which can be financial or other, perhaps difficult to quantify, such as morale, partnerships, or long-term strategy. One of the key considerations in balancing risk options is the cost and effectiveness of any response option; if the value of the asset to the organization is much lower than the security controls required to protect it, risk mitigation or reduction may not be the right option.
Key takeaways
- Risk responses must reduce risk without adversely impacting business processes.
- Risk sharing typically only covers a portion of the risk and does not transfer accountability or responsibility.
- Risk acceptance differs from risk ignorance in that the risk is identified, alternatives are considered, and a conscious decision is made to accept it.
- Risk avoidance is taken when, after all risk treatment options have been considered, the level of risk remains unacceptable.
Thảo luận / Bình luận (0)
Chưa có thảo luận nào cho bài viết này. Hãy gửi bình luận đầu tiên nhé!
Vui lòng Đăng nhập để tham gia thảo luận.